The US Senate’s consideration of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653), a permitting overhaul for energy infrastructure, stalled on 19 November amid a fight over data centres on federal land, Inside Climate News reported. In a 19 November statement, the Center for Western Priorities said Senators Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley had objected the previous night to an agreement on amendment votes after Wyden’s proposed ban on data centres on public lands was excluded.
Key points
- Wyden’s proposed public-land ban was left off the list of possible amendment votes.
- A manager’s amendment would exempt facilities used primarily for internet access or telecommunications from proposed grid-upgrade cost requirements.
- Supporters say the bill would bring $35 billion from data centre operators into the electric grid.
BAAJA’s grid-cost exception
The 495-page bill would accelerate federal permitting for infrastructure including power plants and transmission lines. Its authors say it would leave the law governing data centre siting unchanged. Supporters say its requirements for developers would bring $35 billion into the electric grid to ease costs borne by consumers, Inside Climate News reported. AI Affairs reported the Senate’s earlier vote to advance the bill.
Senator Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma told colleagues the bill would require data centres to pay “100 percent of all grid upgrade cost”. On the same day as Armstrong’s remarks, the bill’s lead sponsors filed a manager’s amendment exempting facilities used primarily for “internet access” or telecommunications from that requirement, according to the Center for Western Priorities. Armstrong, a former chief executive of Williams Companies, also argued that the legislation was important to US data centre and AI leadership.
Earthjustice, an environmental law organisation, concluded that the exception could cover cloud platforms including Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud and Oracle Cloud, the Center for Western Priorities reported. The sponsors’ offices say the wording is intended for home internet providers. Earthjustice is urging Congress to reject BAAJA, arguing that faster permitting would also accelerate construction of pipelines, mines and power plants.
Wyden’s public-land amendment
Opponents argue that faster approval of energy infrastructure would help data centres expand even where the facilities themselves need no federal permit. BAAJA’s authors maintain that the bill would not alter the rules for siting data centres, Inside Climate News reported.
The Center for Western Priorities said Bureau of Land Management records identify proposals for at least 17 data centre campuses and 13 associated infrastructure projects on public holdings covering more than 24,000 acres across Wyoming, Utah, Oregon, Nevada, Idaho and Arizona. On 18 November, 115 conservation, community and faith groups wrote to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins calling for an immediate moratorium on new commercial data centres on public lands.