Latest
AI Affairs, home

Friday 20 November 2026

Government

Madhya Pradesh High Court rebukes state over fictitious AI-drafted citation

The court expects the Advocate General’s office to ensure that counsel verify legal propositions and citations before affidavits are filed.

A shiny black ceremonial gavel rests on its base beside folders.
Photo: Sora Shimazaki via Pexels

In an order dated 17 November, the Madhya Pradesh High Court reprimanded the state government for citing a fictitious Supreme Court judgment in its reply to a dismissed police officer’s petition. Justice Vivek Kumar Singh of the court’s Jabalpur bench said he expected the Advocate General’s office to ensure that citations are checked before affidavits are filed, Lawbeat reported.

Key points

  • The state’s reply paired a non-existent Supreme Court case name with a citation belonging to an unrelated criminal appeal.
  • The court attributed the error to the state’s use of AI drafting tools and cautioned against filing unchecked case law.
  • The court quashed the officer’s dismissal and allowed the state to conduct a regular departmental inquiry.

The state’s false Supreme Court citation

The state cited a purported ruling, State of Andhra Pradesh vs S.S. Mohammad Nisar, as (2008) 5 SCC 230 to argue that evidence could not be reassessed under Article 226 of the Constitution. No such judgment exists, the court found. That citation belongs to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs State (NCT of Delhi), concerning suspension of a sentence in a criminal appeal, Hindustan Times reported.

The court said the state had “blindly resorted” to AI tools in drafting its pleading. It called the reply “callous and irresponsible” and cautioned that inserting fictitious case law without checking citations wasted judicial time and bordered on misleading the court. The court said it expected drafting counsel to verify legal propositions and citations before affidavits were sworn and placed on the record.

Article 311(2)(b) and Tiwari’s dismissal

Piyush Mani Tiwari, an acting sub-inspector at the State Situation Room in Bhopal, was suspended on 26 May 2024 after a woman cleaner complained that he had behaved indecently towards her. The state dismissed him the following day without a departmental inquiry, invoking Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution, which permits an inquiry to be dispensed with when holding one is not reasonably practicable.

The court found that the dismissal order gave no reason why an inquiry was impracticable. When asked to produce the separately recorded reasons, the state provided no contemporaneous record supported by objective material, Lawbeat reported. The court also found no material showing that Tiwari had threatened the complainant or another witness.

The court quashed the dismissal and an appellate order dated 22 July 2024, and directed Tiwari’s reinstatement. It left the state free to hold a regular departmental inquiry under the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966. Back wages will depend on that inquiry’s outcome, and the court expressed no opinion on the allegations against him.

Sources

Topics: Public sector, Regulation, Safety

What should we cover? Tell us

The weekly briefing

The AI Affairs weekly briefing: the week's 10 most important AI stories in business, government and markets, every Monday. We'll email you a link to confirm. Every email has a one-click unsubscribe. Privacy policy